Sunday, July 09, 2006

To my Friends who consider Israel to be the Aggressor

If you are a person to whom this essay is addressed-- Someone who thinks that Israel is far more to blame than the Palestinians, then I can guess a few things about you. The fact is, most people who I've met who share your views are smart, thoughtful, and caring people, so I'll guess that you are also smart, thoughtful and caring. And I'll guess that you've run into people like me-- people who seem reasonable about many things, but have some weird predisposition to take Israel's side which is only explainable by my ignorance or an inability to get past my biases. Did I mention I was Jewish?

The fact is, most people who view Israel as an aggressor believe that the Jews built their nation by wrongly stealing land from the Palestinians. And of course, that colors the picture quite vividly. In your view, suicide bombing may be wrong, but really, the Israelis stole the land in the first place. And Israel's actions against Gaza, the West Bank, Hamas, Arafat before, etc... are all the actions of a country which is trying to keep the land it stole from its victims-- the Palestinians.

You may be thinking that I'm going to cite a bunch of old documents from the British Mandate period: the Sykes-Picot agreement, some League of Nations resolutions, maybe some land or population surveys. Well of course that's not going to work. There are two sides to every story and you know both sides and you've evaluated and picked the other one.

It comes down to this: I'm simply not credible. After all, I'm trying to defend an Aggressor Nation built on stolen land. How credible could I possibly be if I'm doing that? It's like listening to an organized crime lawyer in court-- you might be impressed by his work, but at the end of the day, the lawyer is getting paid to defend organized crime. And even if I'm not explicitly getting paid, I probably have some skin in the game. Did I mention that I am Jewish?

So we've established that you're smart, thoughtful, you know all the stuff I know, and that I'm biased. Well, what can I do? Why am I wasting my time?

I'm going to try to boost my side's credibility with you. If I can raise my credibility over the other side, then maybe you'll listen to me. Ready?

Would you please consider the following proposition: If someone is willing to kill you, then that person is willing to lie to you. Simple enough, right? Killing's a rather bigger deal than lying to most folk. You don't find many truth-telling murderers. And would you please consider extending this to groups and societies? After all, deception is a key element of war.

When you've done considering that proposition, we can move on.

Here's a question: You're very likely to be living in a country in which an attack occurred or was planned by Arab Muslims. You and everyone you care about were a target. Why would you think that you were so special that those who are willing to kill you are not willing to lie to you?

Let's ignore Israel for a second. On Friday, July 7th, the Guardian wrote that:

In the video Tanweer, 22, speaking in his west Yorkshire accent, can be heard justifying his attack on the Aldgate tube in which seven people died and more than a hundred were injured. He says non-Muslims of Britain "deserve to be attacked" because they voted for a government which "continues to oppress our mothers, children, brothers and sisters in Palestine, Afghanistan, Iraq and Chechnya."

Why believe a word of this? Tanweer was so eager to kill Englishmen, he was willing to die to do so. Why believe that his message is truthful? While we're at it, why believe Bin Laden or Zawihiri or Zarqawi?

Now back to Israel: Israel has been around a lot longer than Arab killing of Westerners. That's only been happening the last few decades and you may think it's a result of Israel's aggressions in the first place. Rather cheeky of me-- Israel causes problems and then I use the problems to defend Israel!

Except Israel has not been around a lot longer than Arab killing of Westerners. Remember the Barbary Pirates? How about Vienna? Byzantium? Jihad and the Crusades?

By the way, I'm not denying that there was a lot of Western killing of Arabs. For the purposes of this essay, I don't care who's fault it was or who started it. The fact that your killer is willing to lie to you does not change if you're willing to kill as well.

My point is very simple: It is reasonable to trust the claims of people who are not willing to kill you over the claims of people who are willing to kill you. The Israelis may do things you consider horrible, but they haven't sent any suicide bombers your way. Neither have Americans, nor have the Jews who live amongst you. You really can't say that about the other side. So when both sides have different claims over the legitimacy of the creation of Israel, when both sides are throwing up documents and maps and various translations of UN resolutions and it gets incredibly complicated--- perhaps you might consider that one side is, to put it bluntly, not part of a culture that has been attacking your society for centuries.

Just think about it. Thank You for your time.

3 Comments:

Blogger bleeeeeeeeeeeeeee said...

Miss Lydia slid the letter beneath a celebrex fold of her dress.. You know how it was when I tried to repeat bextra those things to you--I had to go clear back to the beginning when I got interrupted.. The Superintendent showed some seroquel of his old tendencies, as he went round with us.. At this moment the dreamer must have succeeded in prolonging his sleep despite the disturbance, for when he woke he no longer heard the noise; he concluded rightly that some one must zantac have been beating a carpet or bed.. Yes; through my spectacles, he said, turning slowly and clindamycin looking at me with wan solemnity...

April 12, 2007 at 2:09 AM  
Blogger TheMalau said...

BP, I take your points in stride. Now let me try to explain why it is hard for me to support Israel over the Palestinians (even though I am a strong believer in the 2 states solution). I am not Jewish, I am not Muslim, I am not Arab nor other forms of Semites. I am Christian and African.

When you talk about the credibility of people, and you point out the fact that the US and Israel are not part of a culture willing to destroy us to support their claim, I must disagree. Israel trained the elite troops of many oppressing dictators in Africa, perpeuating our suffering, in the name of "Freedom", during the Cold War. During that same period of time, the US installed dictators, killed democratically elected leaders, and generated conflicts and massacres all over the continent, all in the name of "freedom", and against "communism". I must say, as an African, I do not see Israel and the US as better (or worse for that matter) than Arabs, when it comes to credibility.

And ultimately, as far as I am concerned, we should all be wagging our finger at, and nagging the UK for a solution. This is after al a mess they created by their careless "divide and conquer" colonial tactics...

May 3, 2009 at 5:22 PM  
Blogger Internet business at home automated system said...

Want more time with parents and children with family? Can operate as long as the trivial time
Welcome to learn a simple understanding of free market
http://sn.im/vemma_usa
Thank you for your time reading, do not give up the chance to even know, know no loss to you!

July 21, 2010 at 6:48 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home